Local Catholic Churches · Leader answer key
The Bethlehem casebook
Separate Matthew’s clues from Luke’s, then reconstruct the journey to Bethlehem.
1. Which Gospel describes shepherds keeping watch at night when an angel announces Jesus’ birth?
Luke
Luke follows the shepherds from the fields to the manger. Matthew tells of the visit of the magi. Luke 2:8-16
2. Which two gifts does Matthew explicitly name among the magi’s offerings?
Gold • Myrrh
Matthew names gold, frankincense, and myrrh. He gives the list of gifts without giving the number of visitors. Matthew 2:11
3. According to Matthew, where do the magi find the child with Mary?
In a house
Matthew describes the magi entering a house. The manger is a detail from Luke’s account of the birth. Matthew 2:9-11
4. Put these events from Luke in sequence.
Gabriel visits Mary → Mary visits Elizabeth → Jesus is laid in a manger
The Annunciation is followed by the Visitation in Luke 1. Luke 2 describes the journey to Bethlehem and the birth. Luke 1:26-45
5. The magi change their route home. What prompts them?
A warning in a dream
Matthew says they return by another way after a dream warns them against going back to Herod. Matthew 2:12
Talk it through
Which detail comes from the Gospel itself, and which did you first learn from a Nativity scene?
https://localcatholicchurches.com/resource-center/quizzes/bethlehem-casebook/